• About Us
  • Our Services
    • Growth Strategy and Transaction Advisory
    • Tax and Regulatory
    • Transfer Pricing
    • Risk Advisory
    • Startup Ecosystem Solutions
    • GST, Indirect Taxes, Foreign Trade Policy
    • Global Mobility
    • Global Delivery, Outsourcing and Managed Services
    • Private clients and Family Offices
    • Sustainability and ESG Solutions
    • Data Protection & Cyber Security Services
  • Our People
  • Global Offices
  • International Business Desk
    • Korean Desk
    • Japan Desk  ジャパンデスク
  • Insights
    • Newsletters
    • Newsflash
    • India budget statement
    • Events
    • Podcasts
    • Doing Business in India
    • International Newsletters
    • Thought Leadership
    • Knowledge Capsule
    • Report on Modern Energy
    • Report on Significance of Food Fortification and Nutrition
    • Global Compliance Tool
  • Global Presence
  • Code of Ethics
Andersen Global

Worldwide Locations:

  • India
    • Brazil
    • Canada*
    • Chile
    • France
    • Germany
    • Guatemala
    • Ireland*
    • Italy
    • Luxembourg
    • Mexico
    • Netherlands
    • Panama
    • Poland
    • Russia
    • Spain
    • Switzerland
    • United States
  • EN
header-logo
A member firm of Andersen Global®
  • Alumni
  • Media
    • Media Contact
    • ARTICLES IN NEWS PAPERS & JOURNALS
  • Careers
    • Vacancies
    • Apply Online
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Our Services
    • Growth Strategy and Transaction Advisory
    • Tax and Regulatory
    • Transfer Pricing
    • Risk Advisory
    • Startup Ecosystem Solutions
    • GST, Indirect Taxes, Foreign Trade Policy
    • Global Mobility
    • Global Delivery, Outsourcing and Managed Services
    • Private clients and Family Offices
    • Sustainability and ESG Solutions
    • Data Protection & Cyber Security Services
  • Our People
  • Global Offices
  • International Business Desk
    • Korean Desk
    • Japan Desk  ジャパンデスク
  • Insights
    • Newsletters
    • Newsflash
    • India budget statement
    • Events
    • Podcasts
    • Doing Business in India
    • International Newsletters
    • Thought Leadership
    • Knowledge Capsule
    • Report on Modern Energy
    • Report on Significance of Food Fortification and Nutrition
    • Global Compliance Tool
  • Global Presence
  • Code of Ethics

Supreme Court : New Noble Educational Society : Section 10(23C) of the Income Tax Act, 1961

Supreme Court (SC) – accords literal (narrow) interpretation to the word “solely” appearing under section 10(23C) of the Income tax Act, 1961 (the Act) for educational institutions. Overrules Division Bench rulings in Queens Education Society and American Hotel.

SC in a recent ruling1 dismisses batch of appeals arising from a judgment of the Andhra Pradesh High Court (HC) that denied the appellant Trusts the benefit of exemption under section 10(23C) of the Act. Key highlights of the ruling are summarized below. Civil Appeal No. 3795 of 2014 M/s. New Noble Educational Society v. The Chief Commissioner of Income Tax 1 and ANR. with Civil Appeal No. 3793 of 2014; Civil Appeal No. 3794 of 2014; Civil Appeal No. 9108 of 2012; Civil Appeal No. 6418 of 2012.

  1. Section 10(23C) of the Act provides for tax exemption to charitable trusts, societies or institutions existing “solely” for educational purposes and not for the purposes of profit;
  2. The word “solely” was, however, interpreted by two previous Division Bench rulings in 2008 (American Hotel and Lodging Association2) and 2015 (Queen’s Education Society3) to mean that the test for determination was whether the principal or main activity was education or not, rather than whether some profits were incidentally earned. The SC in those rulings followed the “predominant object” test laid down by the Constitution Bench ruling in Surat Art Silk4.
  3. The three-judge bench of the SC headed by Chief Justice of India Uday Umesh Lalit overruled the previous judgments, declaring that the word “solely” must be accorded a literal interpretation since the intent of the legislature is clear that tax exemption should be granted to only those institutions which impart formal scholastic learning. “Education” has been interpreted to be essentially in the nature of a “charitable activity” conducted for upliftment of the society-at-large. The SC, while interpreting the law, relied on the 11-judge bench judgment in the TMA Pai Foundation case of 2002.
Read More

Subscribe to our weekly newsletters

    SHARE:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
  • Print
  • youtube
SOCIAL LINKS
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • youTube
IMPORTANT LINKS
  • India budget statement
  • Newsflash
  • Offices
  • Media
  • Insights
Insights
  • Tax & Regulatory Newsletter
  • Newsflash
  • Doing business in India – simplified
  • Our Brochures
  • ISO Certificates
  • Annual Return (Form MGT-7A)

©Andersen Tax LLC and Nangia Andersen India Pvt. Ltd. is the Indian member firm of Andersen Global, a Swiss verein comprised of legally separate, independent member firms located throughout the world providing services under their own name or the brand "Andersen Tax" or "Andersen Tax & Legal," or "Andersen Legal." Andersen Global does not provide any services and has no responsibility for any actions of the member firms, and the member firms have no responsibility for any actions of Andersen Global. Your use of this website is subject to the terms and conditions governing it. Please read these terms and conditions before using the website.

Terms & Conditions

Subscribe to Regular updates


    Nangia Andersen India Pvt. Ltd.

    Thanks for subscribing.

    Terms & Conditions

    The member firms of Andersen Global cannot obligate each other and are not liable for each other’s acts or omissions. Andersen Global does not provide any services.

    $nbsp:

    We are glad that you preferred to contact us. Please fill our short form and
    one of our team members will contact you back.

      Contact Us

      Talk To Our Experts